Thursday, November 07, 2024

Fashion Uncovered: Sustainability Unsustained - The Issue with the Sustainable Fashion Trend

Thrifting has increased in popularity over the years as fashion trends turn to emphasize 

sustainability and unique styles influenced by the past. Sustainability efforts by many brands and 

designers in the fashion industry has grown as a trend focussing on young, advocated generations

impacted the most by global issues like climate change. As Gen Z myself, efforts to decrease 

contribution to environmental issues and landfills are valuable while shopping.

The Benefits of Thrifting Popularity

Sustainability in fashion has pushed many to shop consciously and thrift for fashion 

forward and vintage pieces. Thrifting is beneficial for the environment and a sustainable 

shopping practice that is fun while being cost and consumption protective. Increased popularity 

in thrifting has resulted in a reduction of clothing contribution to landfills, longer life spans of 

clothing, a decreased rate of overconsumption leading to mindful spending and a cost effective, 

affordable approach to shopping and fashion. Sustainable shopping has also decreased the 

demand for fast-fashion pieces which contributes to the reduction of clothing in landfills. 

The Consequences of the Sustainability Trend

Although an increase in thrifting and sustainable shopping habits are beneficial for the 

fashion world, with anything, an increase in demand leads to an increase in price. Stores 

emphasizing sustainable practices have upped prices knowing that the conscious consumer will 

spend the extra money to purchase recycled and environmentally friendly pieces. This goes with 

everyday brand efforts such as H&M following their recycling program, but it also has been a 

noticed issue with current thrift stores. Popular thrift stores have taken advantage of the 

sustainability trend by increasing prices as demand rises to capitalize on the desires of consumers

without fully contributing to the environmental efforts. Greenwashing is a major issue revolving 

around popular brands known for fast fashion. This is why in order to be a fully conscious 


consumer research is significant before purchasing. Big brands like H&M mentioned earlier may

have recycling efforts in place, but not all garments are fully used. Recycling and donations by 

large companies also can be used to receive tax write offs. Efforts do not always have a 

sustainable motive. 

Regarding thrift stores, there has been ongoing controversy with Value Village 

specifically, and its influx in prices for merchandise donated to them. Driving prices up for items 

that were once affordable is capitalizing on the thrift trend and makes once affordable options for

clothing for those who needed it, unattainable. It is not just fashion forward individuals who 

enjoy thrifting; there are families and individuals out there who only have thrifting as an option 

for clothing. It is not just the prices that are a disadvantage for these consumers either: an 

increase in popularity of thrifting minimizes the availability of clothing options as well. 

Are All Thrift Stores Sustaining Ethical Efforts and Pricing?

One type of retailer that has grown in popularity alongside the thrift trend has been 

consignment shops. We have all seen the baseline effects the sustainability trend has been having

on businesses and consumers with raised prices and increased popularity, but what do businesses 

think about these actions from the inside? I interviewed a local Plato’s Closet manager with eight

years of experience about shifts and patterns noticed in the business as a result of the 

sustainability trend and she has also noticed an influx in prices, however, not as a direct result of 

demand. 

Is Plato’s Closet a Sustainable Brand?

“Yes, I would say that Plato’s is a sustainable brand. By buying and selling gently used 

clothing, we reduce waste and promote the recycling of quality items that may otherwise end up 


in landfills. This resale model supports a circular economy, allowing people to refresh their 

wardrobes affordably while extending the life of clothing.”

Has Plato’s Closet Grown in Popularity as a Result of the Sustainability Trend?

“Yes, absolutely! Thrifting’s popularity has boosted our business and brought more foot 

traffic into the store, especially by Gen Z shoppers. Consumers are increasingly looking for 

budget friendly clothing options that allow them to maintain their style, making our store a great 

choice for those wanting to save money.” 

Do You Believe Plato’s Closet is One of the More Affordable Thrift Options Out There?

“Yes, I believe Plato’s is one of the more affordable thrift options out there alongside 

regular thrift stores selling donated items. In contrast to vintage stores and resellers, we aim to 

keep our prices low and provide our customers with cash for their items, creating a beneficial 

cycle. This affordability makes us a great choice for shoppers looking for quality clothing at 

accessible prices. A bonus at Plato’s Closet is curated, we select our product. So, it’s an easier 

shopping experience.”

Have Prices Gone Up Through the Years as a Result of Increased Demand?

“Prices at Plato's Closet have increased slightly over the years, similar to trends in mall 

stores. However, these changes are very minimal. Our prices are not a result of increased 

popularity. Instead, large demand for a specific category will drive those prices lower. This 

approach helps us remain competitive and affordable while still reflecting the value of quality, 

gently used clothing.”

Do You Feel That Plato’s Business Ethics Have Been Maintained Through the Years?”

“Yes, I believe Plato’s Closet has maintained strong business ethics, especially regarding 

sustainability. We promote responsible consumption by offering affordable, high-quality 


secondhand clothing, which reduces waste and extends the life cycle of garments. By 

encouraging customers to buy and sell gently used items, we minimize the environmental impact

of the fashion industry.”

While most thrift stores have attempted to raise prices and take advantage of their 

increased demand, not all stores are greenwashing and have unsustainable motives. Prices for 

any store go up with inflation, but there is a difference between pricing accordingly on economic

changes and capitalizing on increased demand. Research on renewable practices and brands is 

crucial for conscious consumption and investing in proper, sustainable brands to ensure that 

pricing and practices are sustained. Sustainability has become more noticeably popular which 

has its benefits for the environment but has also led to sustainable motives to be unsustained in 

business practices. 

No comments: